Daniel Zolghadri

Robert

Matthew Maher

Wallace

Miles Emanuel

Miles

Maria Dizzia

Jennifer

Josh Pais

Lewis

Marcia DeBonis

Cheryl

Stephen Adly Guirgis

Mr. Katano

Ron Rifkin

Grandfather

Michael Townsend Wright

Barry

Cleveland Thomas Jr

Steven

Rob M. Anderson

Comic Shop Clerk

Tony Hassini

Richard

Andy Milonakis

George

Mitchell Wenig

Jared

Sylvia Michael Martinez

Pharmacist

Shane Fleming

Gabe

Peter Lucibello

Santa

Constance Shulman

Mrs. Ochs

Charlie Judkins

Comics Expert

Robert Cribbie

Funeral Speaker

Randy Costanza

Funeral Speaker 2

Pamela Dunlap

Judge

Devon Reiff

The Family Lawyer

Michael Quinn

Pharmacy Punk

Tyrone Mitchell Henderson

District Attorney

Michael Citriniti

Pharmacy Customer

Buddy Duress

Ryan

Gore Jones

Card Player

Michael DiBartola

Card Wizard

Jedediah Joseph Smith

Janitor

Louise Lasser

Linda (Pharmacy Lady)

Owen Kline

Comic Shop Customer (uncredited)