Michael Cimino

Cole

Peyton List

Bea

Phoebe Holden

Lydia

Andrea Navedo

Catarina

Brandon Micheal Hall

Mr. Porter

Christine M. Campbell

Teacher 1928

Ethan Herschenfeld

Julian - Tour Guide

Shivani Mendez

Amy - Real Estate Agent

Jesus-Papoleto Melendez

Older Man

Booch O'Connell

Cole's Bandmate

Samantha Everett

Disgruntled Party Guest

Sharleen Shayan

Girl 1

Taip Ceman

Nelson

Jason Kisare

Young Boy

PJ Adzima

Chet

Michael Castillejos

Cole's Dad

Chloé Guerin

Lydia (voice)

Justin Jasiewicz

Boy With Glasses

Ilda Mason

Young Woman

Raina Pellinger

Witch

Jaxon Platon

Pizza Boy

Sequoia Shayvonne

Gatsby Show Girl

Elaine Apruzzese

Pedestrian in 1928 (uncredited)

Bob Leszczak

Museum Guest (uncredited)