Catherine Bell

Joan

Mark Deklin

Beau

Luke Bilyk

Liam

Sage Kitchen

Katie

Mark Bellamy

Charlie

Lorette Clow

Mariann

Joelle Farrow

Young Joan

Ivy Miller

Stacy

Keaira Pliva

Little Girl

Roxanne Wong

Mayor - present day

Griffin Cork

Contest Organizer

Oscar Derkx

Young Beau

Stephanie Wolfe

Paige

Lydia Lau

Baker

Owen Bishop

Harry

Jerry Callaghan

Bob

Ivan Cermak

Peter

Katherine Fadum

Sarah

Zina Lee

Heather

Orin McCusker

Steve

Melanee Murray

Vanessa

Eric Wigston

Morgan

Tenaj Williams

Tommy

Tara Jackson

Bakery Employee (Flashback)

Lara Schmitz

Bakery Employee (Present Day)

Conrad Hild

Priest

Dean Barrett

Mayor (Flashback)

Colette Nwachi

Inn Waitress

Rohini Singh

Bakery Customer Woman