Adam Sandler

Don Truby

Jennifer Garner

Patricia Beltmeyer

Rosemarie DeWitt

Helen Truby

Judy Greer

Donna Clint

Dean Norris

Kent Mooney

Emma Thompson

Narrator (voice)

Timothée Chalamet

Danny Vance

Olivia Crocicchia

Hannah Clint

Kaitlyn Dever

Brandy Beltmeyer

Ansel Elgort

Tim Mooney

Katherine Hughes

Brooke Benton

Elena Kampouris

Allison Doss

Will Peltz

Brandon Lender

Travis Tope

Chris Truby

David Denman

Jim Vance

Dennis Haysbert

Secretluvur

J.K. Simmons

Allison's Dad

Colby Arps

Tanner

Shane Lynch

Angelique

Jason Douglas

Ray Beltmeyer

Phil LaMarr

Shrink

Kaleb King

Rory Pearson

Richard Dillard

Coach

Tina Parker

Allison's Mom

David Jahn

Principal

Jake McDermott

Cal

Kathrine Herzer

Lauren

Helen Estabrook

Wendy Gruding

Kelly O'Malley

School Announcer (voice)

Jeff Witzke

Bartender

Cody Boling

Teacher

Jillian Nicole Jackson

Regina

Dan Gozhansky

Doctor

Tori Black

Tori Black

Irene White

Liz

Luci Christian

Local Casting Rep

Jaren Lewison

Jake Truby

Christina Burdette

Hannah's Friend

Craig Nigh

Anonymous Lover

Karen Smith

Administrator

Candace Lantz

Lydia Mooney

Jon Michael Davis

Greg Cherry

Gene Cervenka

Talent Scout (uncredited)

Edwin S. Nichols III

Car Driver (uncredited)

Nick W. Nicholson

Mayor of East View (uncredited)

Reece Everett Ryan

High School Student (uncredited)