Michael Parks

Pastor Abin Cooper

John Goodman

Joseph Keenan

Melissa Leo

Sara

Michael Angarano

Travis

Kyle Gallner

Jarod

Nicholas Braun

Billy-Ray

Kerry Bishé

Cheyenne

Stephen Root

Sherrif Wynan

Matt Jones

Deputy Pete

Kevin Alejandro

Harry, the Tactical Agent

Ralph Garman

Caleb

Anna Gunn

Travis' Mother

Kevin Pollak

ASAC Brooks

Betty Aberlin

Abigail

Jennifer Schwalbach Smith

Esther

Patrick Fischler

Agent Hammond

Damian Young

Agent Carol

David Marciano

Agent Eccles

Kaylee DeFer

Dana

Ronnie Connell

Randy

Alexa Nikolas

Jesse

Cooper Thornton

Plastic Wrap Man

James Parks

Mordechai

Haley Ramm

Maggie

Elizabeth Tripp

Melanie

Molly Livingston

Fiona May

John Lacy

Travis' Father

Catherine McCord

News Reporter

Deborah Aquila

Mrs. Vasquez

Joey Figueroa

Route 9 Friend

Rose Colasanti

Believer

Carryl Lynn

Believer

Alyssa Petersen

Believer

Bill Cleavelin

Believer

Sadey Paige Nifong

Believer

Scott Nifong

Believer

Gary Sievers

Believer

Marc Blucas

ATF Sniper

Molly Hagan

Janet Keenan

Kevin Smith

Prisoner (voice)

Edward Janda

ATF Agent

Shawn Driscoll

Believer

Marnie Shelton

Believer

Ernest O'Donnell

ATF Agent

Dylan Belardinelli

ATF Agent

Morgan Bertsch

Young look-a-like (uncredited)