Tobin Bell

Jigsaw / John

Costas Mandylor

Hoffman

Scott Patterson

Agent Strahm

Betsy Russell

Jill

Julie Benz

Brit

Meagan Good

Luba

Mark Rolston

Dan Erickson

Carlo Rota

Charles

Greg Bryk

Mallick

Laura Gordon

Ashley

Joris Jarsky

Seth

Mike Butters

Paul

Al Sapienza

Chief of Police

Mike Realba

Detective Fisk

Jeff Pustil

Bernie

Dana Sorman

Law Office Receptionist

Sheila Shah

Special Agent Cowan

Samantha Lemole

Pamela Jenkins

Niamh Wilson

Corbett

Lisa Berry

EMT

Bill Vibert

Officer

Tony Nappo

Gus

Brandon McGibbon

Hank

Timothy Burd

Obi

Natalie Brown

Heather Miller

Quancetia Hamilton

Person with Dog

Lorraine Foreman

Old Woman

Sarah Power

Angelina

Lyriq Bent

Riggs (archive footage)

Athena Karkanis

Agent Perez (archive footage)

Louis Ferreira

Art (archive footage)

Donnie Wahlberg

Eric Matthews (archive footage)

Danny Glover

David Trapp (archive footage)

Shawnee Smith

Amanda (archive footage)

Bahar Soomekh

Lynn (archive footage)

Angus Macfadyen

Jeff (archive footage)

David Gale

Additional Voice Talent (voice)

Catherine Rix

Additional Voice Talent (voice)

Michael A. Miranda

Additional Voice Talent (voice)

Stephen Sparks

Additional Voice Talent (voice)

Jennifer Donison

Additional Voice Talent (voice)

Wayne Curnew

Bartender (uncredited)

Alex Revan

Grayson Blood (uncredited)