Amanda Seyfried

Ann Lee

Lewis Pullman

William Lee

Thomasin McKenzie

Mary Partington / Narrator

Matthew Beard

James Whittaker

Christopher Abbott

Abraham Standerin

Viola Prettejohn

Nancy Lee

David Cale

John Hocknell

Stacy Martin

Jane Wardly

Scott Handy

James Wardley

Jeremy Wheeler

John Townley

Tim Blake Nelson

Pastor Reuben Wight

Daniel Blumberg

Deacon Talmadge Bishop

Willem van der Vegt

Ann's Father

Maria Sand

Ann's Mother

Millie-Rose Crossley

Ann Lee (12 Yrs)

Esmee Hewett

Ann Lee (6 Yrs)

Harry Conway

William Lee (10 Yrs)

Benjamin Bagota

William Lee (4 Yrs)

Scott Alexander Young

Chief Magistrate Tideswell

George Taylor

George Whitefield

Jamie Bogyo

Richard Hocknell

Matti Boustedt

Captain Smith

Alexis Latham

Mr. Cunningham

Shannon Woodward

Mrs. Cunningham

Lark White

Patsy

Roy McCrerey

Mr. Shattuck

Viktória Dányi

Mrs. Shattuck

Natalie Shinnick

Elizabeth Hale

Maddie Browning

Young Mother

Martin O'Regan

Dutchman

Francis McBurney

Infirmary Guard

Alex Gregor

Constable #1

Chris Jackson

Constable #2

Lukas Johne

Jailer

Áron Havasi

Jailer #2

Freya Edmondes

Inmate

Owen Good

Clergyman

James Hogg

Older Deckhand

David Fjällbrant

Young Deckhand #1

Melker Appel

Young Deckhand #2

Laurent Winkler

Builder

Zachary Zamsky

Ruffian #1

Jack LeGoff

Ruffian #2

Maggie Nicols

Townley Woman

Christina Leonardi

Young Shaker Woman

Sasha Bates

Adam

Mattie Vogler

Eve

Emily Leona Rose

Angel

Vivien Piti

Lewd Woman

Gergely Cserhati

Jacob

Josephine Foster

Shaker Singer