Lucy Hale

Jane

Nat Wolff

Will

John Gallagher Jr.

Wallace

Britne Oldford

Audrey

Genevieve Angelson

Eve

Alexander Hodge

Elton

Ward Horton

Mark

Marceline Hugot

Olivia

Laura Kai Chen

Gloria

Mitzi Akaha

Justine

Chase Liefeld

Michael

Avery Cole

Charlotte

Jamie McRae

Erica

Michael Mulheren

Eddie

Reilly Walters

Todd

Federico Rodriguez

Noah

Bria Condon

Amanda

Bryan Enright

Groom

Erin Ruth Walker

Jodi

Shannon O'Neill

Lyft Driver

Carlos Arce Jr.

Campus Security

Paco Lozano

Professor

Kenzie Grey

Juliet (Voice)

Katie Lynn Johnson

Nadine

Cyndee Rivera

Bridesmaid

Nancy Meyer

Kit

Marcus Brandon

Andre

Gene Gillette

Security Guard

Emily Bautista

Marie

Ted Deasy

Jerome

Keenan Laurino

Photographer

Ashley Super

Bill Cardella

Hipster (uncredited)

Alexander Eadie

Valet (uncredited)

Gemma Farquhar

Art Exhibit Guest (uncredited)

Jessica Hottman

Wedding Guest (uncredited)

Laura Lonski

Wedding Guest (Uncredited)

Alicia McDonald

High School Girl (uncredited)

David Sheridan

Wedding Guest (uncredited)

Ashley Spear

Extra (uncredited)