Emilio Estevez

William H. 'Billy the Kid' Bonney

Kiefer Sutherland

Josiah Gordon 'Doc' Scurlock

Lou Diamond Phillips

Jose Chavez y Chavez

Christian Slater

Arkansas Dave Rudabaugh

William L. Petersen

Patrick Floyd 'Pat' Garrett

Alan Ruck

Hendry William French

R. D. Call

D.A. Rynerson

Balthazar Getty

Tom O'Folliard

Jack Kehoe

Ashmun Upson

Robert Knepper

Deputy Carlyle

Tom Kurlander

J.W. Bell

Viggo Mortensen

John W. Poe

Leon Rippy

Robert 'Bob' Ollinger

Tracey Walter

Beever Smith

Bradley Whitford

Charles Phalen

Scott Wilson

Governor Lewis Wallace

James Coburn

John Simpson Chisum

Jenny Wright

Jane Greathouse

Richard Schiff

Rat Bag

Ginger Lynn Allen

Dove

Mickie McGowan

Additional Dialogue Replacement (voice)

Michael Eiland

Shop Keeper

Jon Bon Jovi

Inmate (uncredited)

Alexis Alexander

Dove